Evaluating Corporate Governance and Ethics at Tesco

Tesco Case Study: Navigating Corporate Governance and Ethics Challenges

Introduction

Strong corporate governance and ethics serve as the foundational pillars that guide organizational accountability, stakeholder trust, and long-term sustainability. Corporate governance and ethics play an essential role in organizational success. These critical facets shape the behaviour and success of the company. Corporate governance is a system that contains several rules, processes, and practices to direct and control the organization (Tricker, 2012). Balancing the stakeholders’ interests is one of the key objectives to ensure the long-term success and sustainability of the organization. Board of directors, shareholders, executive compensation, accountability, transparency, and ethical leaders are essential components of corporate governance in the organization. Organizational ethics refers to the rules and values that direct the behaviour of people in the organization. Fair decisions and keeping the social norms in line are critical considerations to be responsible in multiple ways.

This comprehensive study emphasizes corporate governance and ethics issues in the organization to derive valuable insights and implications. It is essential to navigate the organization that has faced corporate governance issues or challenges along with critical analysis of several factors. Of course, the analysis will lead to some solutions for the organization to get things back on track. This critical analysis will also revolve around several learning lessons about governance.

Company Background: Tesco

Tesco is a large retail organization in the United Kingdom. Jack Cohen founded this organization in 1919. The firm has gained and sustained success in the competitive retail industry due to its more considerable scalability, affordable retail items, and incredible growth and expansion. In 2023, the firm’s revenue reached £65.762 billion (Bedford, 2024). Since its origin, the firm has maintained effective corporate governance and ethics in the internal business climate. However, in this contemporary business era, some issues and challenges are in the limelight. Tesco has the potential to evade these CG issues and become more responsible in the retail industry.

Organization’s Board Structure and Processes

Tesco’s Board’s structure is dynamic, as it contains ten members. The Board of directors remains at the top level, including the CEO. This Board designs the firm’s strategy, oversees operations, and sets the foundation for long-term success and growth. In this board structure, the chair is liable for fostering a culture that encourages open dialogue and transparency. Board building has also been effective, as far as the varying perspectives in the decision-making are concerned. All directors usually get accurate information. Communication with stakeholders and shareholders is also effective, indicating the smooth functioning of the structure.

Critical Issues

Critically, the Board of structure has stumbled due to potential issues. For instance, there needs to be more diversity on the Board. Lack of diversity is leading to the lack of viewpoints in decision-making. Diverse perspectives are apparent, but it is always imperative to represent the border customer base. So far, the diversity targets in the broad structure still need to be clarified, which is becoming a significant concern for the organization. In this context, the organization needs to enable consistent assessment to address this critical issue (Jahshan, 2018).

Enabling a good balance between non-executives and executives is necessary. The contribution of independent executives is limited. Indeed, they can streamline unbiased oversight of the Board. Again, this issue can be addressed by conducting frequent assessments of the Board’s independence. The firm needs to improve its risk management function. In this rapidly changing business climate, the organization usually makes quick decisions without assessing risks. Thus, practical risk discussions are essential to evade this issue. The most important thing is to evaluate the emerging risks to set the foundation for risk mitigation approaches (Grocerygazette.co.uk, 2022).

Succession planning has been an issue for the organization as far as the key leadership positions are concerned. Tesco’s succession planning has been conventional, as it could have involved the identification of the talent in the organization to set the ground for stability and continuity. Eventually, Tesco needs consistent board evaluation. It is essential to navigate the effectiveness of the Board, including the performance of directors and committees. The ultimate objective must be to enhance the organization’s objectivity in the dynamic business landscape (Atwood, 2020).

Addressing Issues

Corporate Governance Landscape (Learnsignal.com, 2023)

The concept of the corporate governance landscape is evident, as it can set the base for Tesco to address these issues. For instance, Enron’s scandal has been a landmark event regarding the probable failure of corporate governance. It streamlines the significance of robust oversight and diversity in the board structure. Tesco can bring more diverse viewpoints to its broad structures to reduce the probability of a similar issue. For example, Tesco’s accounting scandal optimizes a similar concern about the effectiveness of the Board and probable conflict of interest.

UK Reform

Apart from that, Tesco needs to shape effective compliance, especially in the context of the UK reform regarding board composition, transparency, and risk management. It is compelling the organization to conduct consistent assessments and changes to integrate with the evolved governance standards. The excessive focus has remained on shareholder value. It creates a dilemma for the Board, as social and environmental efforts or decisions typically go beyond shareholder interest and value. It is the best time to steer the influence of social and ecological decisions on all key stakeholders, including government, suppliers, customers, employees, shareholders, and the environment (The Diligent team, 2023).

Application of Agency Theory

The application of agency theory is relevant, as it streamlines the probable conflicts between managers and shareholders. Agency theory indicates that managers act on behalf of stakeholders, which refers to principles, to enhance the wealth of shareholders. However, there has been an information asymmetry, as managers or executives contain excessive information about shareholders. This moral hazard can be addressed by creating a balance between short-term and long-term gains (Bonazzi and Islam, 2007). Balancing shareholder value and ethical conduct is crucial to move forward. Poor oversight mechanism permits managers more discretion. Thus, Tesco must strive for an independent board with an influential committee (oversight) to maintain proper checks and balances on actions at the management level. The critical assumption is that Tesco’s Board must align with the shareholders’ values.

Financial Structure and Situation

Debt-to-equity ratio, capital expenditures, and working capital management are essential components of the financial structure of the organization. Tesco’s DE shows the proportion of debt relative to equity financing. So far, the firm has shown its commitments (investments) in capital expenditures as far as store expansion, technology adoption, and infrastructure are concerned. Critically high capital expenditures are leading to the influence on financial stability. Tesco can optimize the working capital that always influences profitability and liquidity (Li, 2023).

Critical Issues

Historically, Tesco has stumbled due to high debt levels and its rapid global expansion strategies. The firm has been vulnerable due to the probable economic downturn and its lower capability to invest in new things. For example, the influence of the 2008 financial crisis was devastating, as debt levels increased with less probability of growth and expansion (Mathiason, 2008). Investor confidence was also desired when the firm was accused of overstating its profit. Currently, profit margins have shrunk, and the influence of Aldi and Lidl is apparent. These discount stories and new trends made it challenging to generate maximum profits. Inflation and supply chain disruptions (Brexit and pandemic) also ruined the profitability target or objectives. Intense competition from online retailers is also leading to declining market share, becoming a significant concern for the organization (Chapman, 2021).

Addressing Issues

Trends in Finance and Sustainability

Integrating with new trends in finance and sustainability is the best approach to address these issues. For instance, a focus on sustainability has been the best intervention to get things on track. There is a need to enhance investor interest in the social, environmental, and governance aspects. The critical assumption is that the firm must demonstrate intentions regarding responsible business practices in its operations. It is all about attracting sustainable investments to get rid of the financial decline and enhance its reputation. Alternatively, the governance system must strive for technological advancement. The most important thing for Tesco is to leverage these advanced technologies to improve its financial reporting system and strengthen the overall internal process. Technology integration will make the organization, especially its governance system, more data-centric, and it can further lead to better decision-making process (Marr, 2020).

Digital Disruption

Digital disruption is also in the spotlight, as it influences the governance system of the organization. In this changing and evolving customer landscape, digital interventions are shaping customer behaviours. Expectations regarding online shopping and personalization are apparent (Modernretail.co.uk, 2020). Thus, in this context, the Tesco board needs to make some changes in its governance system to address this dynamically changing situation. Maintaining a solid digital presence in the market should be the key objective. Reliance on advanced technology is growing. But it is also increasing the cybersecurity risks. In the highly digitized world, the Board must consider new and progressive cybersecurity measures to protect financial and consumer information.

Balancing Debt & Investments

Tesco needs to reduce the debt burden to set the foundation for sustainable growth. Maintaining the right balance between debt and further investment is the right approach. The critical assumption is that the firm must incorporate ESG principles in its core functions. There is a need to improve transparency in the reporting process to sustain its image. It can facilitate ESG-focused investors. The Board needs to contain processes and structure to be relevant in this digital age. For instance, Tesco needs more directors with excessive digital expertise. A precise and progressive digital governance framework must be introduced, which can further drive innovation and adoption (Kuzey et al., 2023).

Risk and its Internal Control Systems

Tesco has faced several risks along with some complications regarding internal controls. The detailed illustration is as follows.

Financial Risks: Tesco has stumbled due to excessive market fluctuations. A shift in consumer habits, the economic situation, and the exchange rate have hit the firm’s cash flow and profitability. Also, the firm is currently facing a debt burden, which is jeopardizing financial stability.

Operating Risks: Tesco is currently facing multiple supply chain disruptions. Political instability, Brexit, and the pandemic have been some critical aspects that enhanced this disruption. These daunting operational challenges have limited the firm’s capability to source and deliver to its full potential. Technology is also disrupting. Tesco can fail to adopt the new technologies, which can lead to a limited competitive edge. Many product recalls and quality issues have already been daunting for the organization. Thus, the probability of financial and reputation losses is high (CIO, 2014).

Reputational Risks: There have been many sustainability concerns. Investors and consumers have become socially and environmentally conscious, compelling Tesco to depict responsible business practices. Several cyberattacks have become significant risks as far as the customer and financial data are concerned. Tesco’s financial system can be hit in the form of penalties.

Internal Control Systems

Preventive Controls: Tesco has implemented internal control systems to evade its risks and maintain efficiency. For instance, preventive controls are apparent. These are the combination of specific policies and procedures, such as financial reporting, data security, and procurement. These policies and procedures have compelled employees to adopt best practices. Segregation of duties at Tesco is also adequate. Recording, authorization, and asset custody are contributing to better fraud mitigation. Apart from that, conducting frequent audits and assessments is a norm at Tesco. Tesco identifies and addresses potential weaknesses or flaws in these internal controls.

Detective Controls: The firm maintains detective controls that help to recognize risks that occur. For instance, the management conducts variance analysis to compare actual outcomes with expected outcomes. It is all about recognizing discrepancies and areas for further scrutiny. Inventory control has also been maintained through the inventory control system. Employees are provided whistleblowing protocols or channels to evade the probability of misconduct (Theguardian.com, 2014).

Corrective Controls: Tesco also shows some disciplinary actions for the recognized misconduct or breaches. The most important thing is reinforcing the integration with the set ethical standards in the internal business climate.

Addressing Issues

Global Governance Variances

Tesco needs to address the internal control issues by aligning with global governance variances. In Europe, corporate governance is triggered by co-determination. Many employee representatives are part of the decision-making function, especially in board meetings. It is a good collaboration that always facilitates maintaining internal controls. Ownership, especially in risk management, is critical, and it is what Tesco needs to consider moving forward. Comparatively, in the United States, the governance system depends on shareholder value (Naciri, 2008). Organizations prefer excessive value for shareholders to improve efficiency.

Nonetheless, critically, firms usually ignore employee concerns and further risk management facets that are not directly influential. China, on the other hand, depicts a state-centric governance system. In this country, the government is quite influential in the governance system, leading to robust top-down structures (Jia and Tomasic, 2009).

Balanced Approach

Tesco needs to come up with a balanced approach as far as these governance variances are concerned. For instance, Tesco needs to incorporate the co-determination principle from the European governance system. It is all about involving employees in board meetings and the decision-making process. Fostering ownership at the employee level can lead to more internal controls. It is the best time for this retail giant to contain the long-term focus. Long-term viewpoints must be embedded in the control structure or framework. Social, environmental, and reputational risks must be prioritized (Naciri, 2008). The governance model in the United States has some limitations. It is essential to improve independent oversight mechanisms to bring a more dedicated and practical risk management approach. Tesco’s management needs to comprehend different cultural factors. For example, tailoring the internal control communication according to the cultural context is mandatory. This cultural influence can resonate with a diverse workforce and set the foundation for broader inclusion (Tricker, 2012).

Stewardship Theory

Tesco lacks a long-term vision due to the excessive concentration of short-term financial gains. Stewardship theory is relevant, as the organization must promote the culture of ethical leadership in the internal setting. Tesco needs to prioritize ethical behaviours in the internal setting, and adequate training can become the best driver of it. This training can help the company improve compliance and risk management practices. Internally, there is a need to align compensation with the long-term goal instead of just sticking to the short-term gains. The management must have performance incentives that must be aligned with the long-term objectives. Ethical conduct and liable risk management should also be in the loop. Eventually, stewardship theory also stresses continuous improvement. The most important thing is to assess the internal controls and have valuable feedback for stakeholders. Recognizing the areas for improvement and containing a practical control framework is essential (Rezaee and Safarzadeh, 2023).

Relationships with and Organization of Different Stakeholder Groups

Tesco is also facing issues regarding relationships with stakeholders. Several stakeholders, such as customers, employees, investors, suppliers, and communities, are apparent. The brief illustration is as follows.

Critical Issues

Customers: As discussed, Tesco is facing intense competition due to the rise of discount stores. It is leading to a declining market share. The firm needs to meet the new customer expectations and preferences, leading to excessive dissatisfaction. In this dynamic retail landscape, customer’s expectations are changing as they strive for personalization, convenience, and ethical sourcing. Tesco has yet to reach its full potential to build and sustain relationships with its customers (Marlow, 2023).

Employees: Hectic working conditions in the internal business climate have become a significant concern for the organization. Employee morale could be improved and more probable, especially in the warehouse. The communication system needs to be clarified and transparent, and a positive work environment must be shaped to enhance employee engagement (Lamb, 2022).

Investors: Tesco needs to gain investors’ confidence, hindering investments. Accounting scandals and the rapid decline in the firm’s financial gains are significant concerns. Tesco must strive for more transparency, especially in its communication with investors.

Communities: Community engagement is also limited due to a need for progressive community initiatives. As discussed, customers and communities have become socially and environmentally conscious, and Tesco has yet to show its commitment to be relevant.

Addressing Issues

Tesco needs to apply stakeholder theory to address this issue. This theory stresses that the business should not only concentrate on shareholder value but must also meet the expectations of all key stakeholders.

Recognizing and Prioritizing: Stakeholder Theory

First, the organization needs to recognize stakeholder groups and concerns, and this is the fundamental aspect. The firm has identified these stakeholders, but there is a need to be more transparent and more precise about the stakeholders’ priorities. The critical assumption is that the firm must conduct consistent stakeholder engagement initiatives. These may include surveys, consultations, and focus groups. It is all about making the organization capable of comprehending its expectations and setting the ground for improvements (Friedman and Miles, 2006).

Balancing Value

Creating a balance regarding stakeholder trust is essential. For instance, instead of just concentrating on high returns and shareholder value, the firm needs to offer competitive wages, foster a positive work climate, and streamline benefits for stakeholders, such as employees. Another assumption is that the management must preserve financial stability when offering competitive benefits to its employees. Executing sustainable sourcing practices is also a key consideration to maximize the benefits for the environment and suppliers. The new measures must trigger scrutiny at the supplier level. The new supplier criteria will also shape the behaviour of suppliers to make Tesco responsible (Tricker, 2012).

Building Long Term Relationship

Tesco needs to build long-term relationships with different stakeholder groups. The most important thing is enabling mutual respect. For instance, there is a need to enhance collaboration when talking about initiatives. Addressing shared goals and preserving sustainability and community engagement are good considerations (Naciri, 2008). In this context, the organization needs to invest in the training and development program that can lead to further skill development. The ultimate objective is to create value for these stakeholders instead of just focusing on short-term financial gains.

Relevant Social and Ethical Issues

Tesco is facing social and ethical issues in many ways. There is a need to take a careful approach to address these issues to make the business liable and relevant in the retail industry.

Critical Issues & Solutions

Supply Chain: Unfair labour practices have become a concern, especially in terms of working conditions, human rights, and wages. The firm has been accused of forced labour, hectic working conditions, and wage gaps in the operating countries. This ethical and social issue is running the firm’s reputation or image in the business landscape. Conversely, sourcing, logistics, and production also influence the environment. For example, these components of the business are leading to deforestation, energy consumption, and unfair agriculture practices.

Diversity and Inclusion: Tesco intends to champion diversity and inclusion to justify social responsibility. However, the number of women in leadership or managerial positions is still lower than that of men (Gonçalves, 2022). The inclusion of women as leaders or managers is still a paradox for the organization. It is necessary to maintain equal opportunities for all when it comes to promotion, compensation, and the right to participate. Discrimination based on age, gender, ethnic background, and other factors is common, and Tesco needs to get rid of it to become more responsible.

Environmental Impact: Tesco needs to reduce its environmental impact by reducing its carbon footprint. Carbon emission targets have been set, but the firm needs to progress in its energy consumption, transportation solutions, and waste management approaches. Sustainable packaging solutions can be the first step for the organization. Sustainability must be incorporated into the corporate governance system to shape behaviours and intentions (Kamal, 2021).

Conclusion

It concludes that Tesco has the potential to move forward with better CG and ethical measures. Making the business responsible in the internal and external business landscape is essential, and the firm needs to implement all solutions or strategies with improvisation. This comprehensive analysis critically analyses corporate governance and ethical issues at Tesco. The impact of these issues or challenges on Tesco’s operations and stakeholders is negative. The study has incorporated key lessons and theories in solutions. Tesco needs to be adaptive and resilient when considering these solutions. Trends are changing, and keeping the business relevant is the best assumption.

References

Atwood, C., 2020. Succession Planning Basics, 2nd Edition. Association for Talent Development.

Bedford, E., 2024. Percentage change in sales at Tesco in Great Britain compared to a year earlier from January 2015 to October 2023. [Online] Available at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/386598/tesco-sales-percentage-change-great-britain-uk/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Bonazzi, L. and Islam, S.M.N., 2007. Agency theory and corporate governance: A study of the effectiveness of board in their monitoring of the CEO. Journal of Modelling in Management, 2(1), p.7.

Chapman, B., 2021. Tesco hit by Brexit disruption shipping goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. [Online] Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/brexit-food-tesco-northern-ireland-b1787272.html [Accessed 29 February 2024].

CIO, 2014. Tesco needs to listen to new blood. [Online] Available at: https://www.cio.com/article/199571/tesco-needs-to-listen-to-new-blood.html [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Friedman, A.L. and Miles, S., 2006. Stakeholders: Theory and Practice. OUP Oxford.

Gonçalves, M., 2022. The 10 Most Powerful Women In Food, Drink And Grocery. [Online] Available at: https://www.thegrocer.co.uk/people/women-in-power-we-need-to-change-the-industry-from-the-inside/666149.article [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Grocerygazette.co.uk, 2022. Tesco Adds New Independent Non-Executive Director To Board. [Online] Available at: https://www.grocerygazette.co.uk/2022/09/21/caroline-silver-tesco/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Jahshan, E., 2018. Tesco chairman pledges to diversify all-white board of directors. [Online] Available at: https://www.retailgazette.co.uk/blog/2018/06/tesco-chairman-makes-pledge-diversify-white-board-directors/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Jia, X. and Tomasic, R., 2009. Corporate Governance and Resource Security in China: The Transformation of China’s Global Resources Companies. Routledge.

Kamal, Y., 2021. Stakeholders expectations for CSR-related corporate governance disclosure: evidence from a developing country. Asian Review of Accounting, 29(2), pp.97-127.

Kuzey, C., Al-Shaer, H., Karaman, A.S. and Uyar, A., 2023. Public governance, corporate governance and excessive ESG. Corporate Governance, 23(7), pp.1748-77.

Lamb, J., 2022. Tesco slammed over poor working conditions at supplier’s factory. [Online] Available at: https://www.proactiveinvestors.co.uk/companies/news/1001670/tesco-slammed-over-poor-working-conditions-at-supplier-s-factory-1001670.html [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Learnsignal.com, 2023. The Enron Scandal: A Comprehensive Overview. [Online] Available at: https://www.learnsignal.com/blog/the-enron-scandal-overview/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Li, S., 2023. Analysis of Tesco’s Financial Status Quo Based on Financial Ratio Analysis. Advances in Economics Management and Political Sciences, 30(1), pp.103-09.

Marlow, B., 2023. Tesco is losing the plot in its battle with Aldi and Lidl. [Online] Available at: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/02/01/tesco-losing-plot-battle-aldi-lidl/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Marr, B., 2020. The 6 Biggest Technology Trends In Accounting And Finance. [Online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2020/07/27/the-6-biggest-technology-trends-in-accounting-and-finance/?sh=ad6b2073c7ef [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Mathiason, N., 2008. Tesco posts worst figures in 16 years. [Online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2008/nov/30/tesco-retail-supermarkets-business-recession [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Modernretail.co.uk, 2020. Personalisation In Retail. [Online] Available at: https://modernretail.co.uk/personalisation-in-retail/ [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Naciri, A., 2008. Corporate Governance Around the World. Routledge.

Rezaee, Z. and Safarzadeh, M.H., 2023. Corporate governance and earnings quality: the behavioral theory of corporate governance (evidence from Iran). Corporate Governance; Bradford, 23(1), pp.189-218.

The Diligent team, 2023. What’s Going on with UK Corporate Governance and Audit Reform? [Online] Available at: https://www.diligent.com/resources/blog/uk-corporate-governance-and-audit-reform [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Theguardian.com, 2014. The Guardian view on Tesco’s auditing debacle: a systemic shambles? [Online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/oct/23/guardian-view-tesco-auditing-debacle-pwc-systemic-shambles [Accessed 29 February 2024].

Tricker, R.I., 2012. Corporate Governance: Principles, Policies and Practices. OUP Oxford.

Need help with this topic?

Get one-to-one tutoring or feedback on your own draft. We reply with a fixed price and deadline.

You May also Like These Notes and Samples

Need Help With Your Studies?

Start with the free notes, or ask for a fixed-price quote for tutoring and feedback.

Chat on WhatsApp